The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a spousal
sponsorship application after the Immigration Appeal Division found that the
marriage was not genuine and had been entered into primarily for immigration
purposes.
The sponsor and his wife gave conflicting information about
where they lived together, when they met each other’s families, and a temporary
resident visa application made by the sponsored spouse.
The Court upheld the refusal because the inconsistencies
were significant enough to reasonably undermine the couple’s credibility.
Key Principle
In a spousal sponsorship application, immigration
authorities may look beyond the marriage certificate and examine whether the
relationship is genuine.
Consistency matters.
Contradictory answers about important parts of the
relationship, including cohabitation, family involvement, previous visa
applications, and relationship history, can seriously damage the credibility of
both spouses.
Even where some evidence supports the relationship,
significant credibility concerns may outweigh those positive factors.
Background
The sponsor was a 75-year-old Canadian citizen originally
from Guyana. His wife was 47 years old and lived in Guyana.
They first spoke by telephone on April 27, 2009, met in
person two days later, and married in an Islamic ceremony on May 3, 2009.
The sponsor returned to Canada on May 6, 2009. He later
returned to Guyana, and the couple completed a civil marriage ceremony in
January 2010.
The sponsored spouse had also applied for a temporary
resident visa in November 2009, which was refused.
The sponsor subsequently filed an overseas spousal
sponsorship application. A visa officer refused it, and the IAD later dismissed
the sponsorship appeal.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the IAD had reasonably relied
on numerous inconsistencies concerning the couple’s cohabitation.
Different documents and testimony provided different
accounts of whether the couple lived together after the Islamic marriage,
during the sponsor’s later visit to Guyana, or only after their civil marriage.
The Court held that these contradictions were important
because they concerned a central aspect of the couple’s relationship.
The IAD also considered the sponsored spouse’s temporary
resident visa application.
In that application, she had described herself as widowed,
despite having already participated in the Islamic marriage ceremony, and
stated that she was travelling to Canada to visit a cousin.
Her explanation was that she intended to surprise her
husband. However, the sponsor and sponsored spouse gave inconsistent accounts
about whether he knew about the visa application and about the identity of the
alleged cousin.
The sponsor also admitted that part of an affidavit
previously submitted in the immigration proceedings was not truthful.
Additional inconsistencies concerned when the sponsored
spouse first met members of the sponsor’s family.
The Court found that the IAD was entitled to consider these
discrepancies as part of its overall credibility assessment.
The sponsor argued that several positive relationship
factors supported the marriage.
The Court acknowledged that some of the commonly used
indicators of a genuine marriage may have been satisfied. However, the IAD
reasonably concluded that the significant inconsistencies and credibility
problems outweighed those positive factors.
A relationship assessment must consider the evidence as a
whole. Meeting some indicators of genuineness does not require approval where
other evidence raises serious credibility concerns.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review and upheld the IAD’s decision.
The Court concluded that the sponsor had not established, on
a balance of probabilities, that the marriage fell outside the
marriage-of-convenience provisions of the Immigration and Refugee Protection
Regulations.
Case Citation:
Khan v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 320 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst





