Thanusha Tharmarasa sought
judicial review after the Immigration Appeal Division dismissed her
humanitarian and compassionate appeal concerning the refusal of her application
to sponsor her mother and three dependent siblings. The IAD assessed her 2009 application
under more stringent regulations introduced in 2014. The Federal Court held
that the earlier regulations applied and that using the newer income
requirements also improperly elevated the threshold in the IAD’s H&C
analysis.
Key Principle
A sponsorship application filed
before November 5, 2011 under the Parents and Grandparents Program must be
assessed under the regulations in force when it was received. A Regulatory
Impact Analysis Statement may be used to determine the intended application of
regulatory amendments. Where applying the wrong regulations creates an
artificial financial shortfall and leads the IAD to impose a heightened H&C
threshold, the resulting decision is unreasonable.
Background
Tharmarasa, a Sri Lankan citizen
who became a Canadian permanent resident in 2007, applied in 2009 to sponsor
her widowed mother and three younger siblings. Her husband later became a
co-signatory.
When the application was filed,
the applicable regulations required minimum necessary income equal to the Low
Income Cut-Off for one year preceding the application. New regulations
effective January 2014 increased the requirement to LICO plus 30 percent and
used a three-year assessment period.
An immigration officer refused
the application in 2015 because Tharmarasa did not satisfy the income
requirement under the old rules. She appealed only on H&C grounds.
The IAD treated the appeal as a
de novo proceeding and concluded that the 2014 regulations applied because no
rights had accrued until its final decision. Under those rules, it identified
substantial income shortfalls and stated that an “abundance” of H&C factors
was required to overcome them.
Court Findings
• Regulatory Impact Statement
Clarified Which Rules Applied
The Court considered the
Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement accompanying the 2014 amendments. It
expressly stated that Parents and Grandparents Program applications received
before the November 5, 2011 pause would be assessed under the regulations then
in force, while applications received from January 2, 2014 onward would be
assessed under the new regulations.
• IAD Unreasonably Applied the
New Regulations
Because Tharmarasa filed her
sponsorship application in 2009, the Court found that Parliament’s intended
application of the amendments was clear. The IAD was obliged to assess the
sponsorship under the old regulations. Its reliance on Gill was
misplaced because that decision did not address the transition to the new
regulations or the Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement.
The Court distinguished earlier
decisions applying the new regulations to older applications because neither
had considered the Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement.
• Wrong Income Rules Distorted
the H&C Analysis
Applying the new regulations
produced significant financial shortfalls that became material to the IAD’s
H&C assessment. The IAD consequently required an abundance of positive
H&C considerations and applied a higher threshold. Because that heightened
approach flowed from applying the wrong financial rules, the H&C analysis
was also unreasonable.
Outcome
The Federal Court granted
judicial review and ordered that the sponsorship appeal be redetermined by a
different IAD panel under the old regulations. No question was certified.
Case
Citation:
Tharmarasa v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2018 FC 1174 (CanLII)
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst





