NOC PFL: Job Duties & NOC mismatch
One
of the most common PFL & Refusal Reasons is a mismatch between the NOC and
job duties. An applicant may receive a Procedural Fairness Letter
(PFL) if the officer has concerns about the applicant’s employment
title and the main duties listed in their employment
letter.
While
submitting an EOI, the first step is to review the official NOC description for
your declared occupation. Each NOC occupation contains two major factors: a
lead statement and a list of main duties. Under Section 80(3)(a)
and (b)
of the IRPR for the Federal Skilled Worker Program and Section 87.1(2)(b)
and (c)
for the Canadian Experience Class, applicants must demonstrate that they
performed the actions described in the “lead statement” and “a substantial
number of the main duties”, including all essential duties. Employment
requirements are generally not the primary factors in assessing whether an
applicant’s work experience corresponds to the declared NOC as per law.
Furthermore,
Section 11(1)
of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA) requires applicants to
meet the requirements of the Act before a visa or other immigration document
can be issued. Section 11.2
of the IRPA further establishes that an officer cannot issue a permanent
residence visa to an Express Entry applicant who did not possess the
qualifications on which they were ranked and invited to apply. Therefore, it is
important to ensure that your declared NOC and supporting employment evidence
accurately reflect your actual work experience and qualifications.
For
example, an applicant may declare a managerial occupation because their job
title includes the words Store Manager (60020). However, their employment
letter may primarily describe duties like coordinating sales staff and
cashiers, shelving, and merchandising, without establishing the management
functions associated with the declared occupation. In such cases, their actual
duties might fall under a Supervisor NOC (62010), even if the title says
Manager.
It is also important to understand that your
employment duties do not necessarily have to use the exact wording found in the
NOC. But there should be substantial number of the main duties like 70% to 80%
similarity between your duties and those mentioned in the NOC. If the mismatch
is more than 30%, then you should consider providing an explanation with your
application outlining why the declared NOC is appropriate for your job to avoid
any PFL or concerns from the officer. Keep in mind that, you are giving 30%
chance to the visa officer to send PFL.
If you receive a PFL questioning your declared NOC,
you should carefully review the officer’s concerns and identify evidence that
directly addresses the concerns raised in the letter regarding your duties. It
is very important to justify your core duties and make your explanation
credible using the evidences already submitted. Hence, the duties mentioned in
the initial employment letter is crucial in both PNP & Express Entry
applications. Therefore, ensure that your initial employment letter includes a
complete and accurate description of your job duties so that your employer can
provide further clarification and support your position if a PFL is issued
later.
To
justify your situation, you can also utilize Canadian immigration case laws
that shows how visa officers may look at your concern and how you can prove
sufficiently detailed employment evidence when an officer assesses an
applicant’s work experience corresponds to a declared NOC. Our online Canadian immigration case law library is organized by topic, so you can quickly find court decisions
that match your situation.
In
Sing v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2026 FC
105, the Federal Court
overturned a refusal after finding that the officer had unreasonably assessed
the applicant’s employment responsibilities.
A
PFL is an important opportunity to respond to concerns before a final decision
is made. If you think your NOC selection may involve complications, then you
can seek expert advice to determine your NOC
correctly and prepare an appropriate response to your PFL.
At A&M Canadian Immigration Law Corporation, Dr. Muhammad Abrar, PhD in Law, provides legal assistance with complex NOC related Procedural Fairness Letters. Our Canadian Immigration Case Law Library also provides access to Federal Court decisions organized by immigration topic, helping applicants and legal professionals identify relevant legal principles when preparing their responses.
Frequently Asked Questions
1.
What happens if some of my job duties do not match the declared NOC?
Not
every responsibility must necessarily be identical to the NOC description.
However, you should examine whether the overall nature of your employment and
the relevant main duties support your declared occupation.
2.
Does my job title have to match my declared NOC?
Not
necessarily. Your job title does not independently determine your NOC.
The actual responsibilities you perform and their correspondence with the
occupational description are important considerations
3.
How to determine correct NOC?
Check
the NOC’s lead statement and detailed job responsibilities to determine the
correct NOC. If you are unable to determine which NOC your job falls under,
seek professional advice to avoid any PFL or rejection due to NOC issues.
Written by: Dr.
Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Sources: MPNP
Application Assessment | MPNP Supporting
Documents | National Occupational
Classification |
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law
and Statistics Analyst






