The Federal Court dismissed
judicial review of the rejection of the Applicant’s Federal Skilled Worker
Express Entry application as incomplete. Although the Applicant demonstrated
that she possessed more than sufficient settlement funds, she failed to provide
the required official letter from her financial institution verifying
her financial profile. The Court held that IRCC was entitled to require this
additional level of verification and that the Applicant had already been
clearly notified of the requirement through the online application system.
Key Principle
Although the Immigration and
Refugee Protection Regulations required proof of settlement funds, they did
not prescribe the precise form of evidence required. Nevertheless, visa
officers have a duty to assess the reliability of documents, and IRCC may
reasonably require additional verification of financial information. An
applicant who has been clearly informed of a documentary requirement before
submitting the application cannot generally claim procedural unfairness because
the application is rejected for failing to satisfy that requirement.
Background
The Applicant, a Brazilian
citizen, had completed post-secondary education in Brazil and Canada and worked
in administrative positions in Canada. In February 2016, she created an Express
Entry profile and subsequently received an invitation to apply for permanent
residence under the Federal Skilled Worker Class with a score of 465.
With her PR application, the
Applicant submitted various TD Canada Trust statements showing mutual funds,
TFSA holdings, chequing accounts and other investments. Collectively, the
documents demonstrated more than $43,000 in Canadian funds, well above the
applicable settlement-fund requirement.
IRCC nevertheless rejected the
application as incomplete because the Applicant had not provided an official
financial institution letter listing her accounts, account numbers, opening
dates, balances, debts and the institution’s contact information. The online
application itself contained a text box expressly advising applicants of this
requirement.
Court Findings
• Clear notice of the
documentary requirement: The Applicant had been expressly informed through
the online application that proof of funds had to include an official letter
printed on the financial institution’s letterhead. Because she had received
this notice before filing, there was no procedural unfairness in rejecting the
application without another fairness letter.
• Sufficiency and verification
are different: Although the Applicant had enough money, the issue was not
simply the amount of funds. IRCC was entitled to require documentation allowing
the Officer to verify the financial information directly with the financial
institution.
• IRCC could impose additional
verification requirements: The Regulations did not specify the precise form
of proof, but the Court held that this did not prevent visa officers or IRCC
from reasonably requiring a particular level of verification. The requirement
for an official bank letter was considered reasonable.
• No fettering of discretion:
The Court rejected the argument that IRCC had improperly predetermined what
evidence must be accepted. Visa officers are responsible for weighing and
assessing documents, and requiring reliable verification was connected to that
responsibility rather than an improper fettering of discretion.
• Applicant did not cure the
deficiency on reconsideration: Although IRCC reconsidered the matter, the
Applicant submitted essentially the same documents again, which still did not
comply with the clearly stated requirement.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the
judicial review application and found no breach of procedural fairness or
unreasonable exercise of discretion. No question was certified and there was no
order as to costs.
Case
Citation:
Gugliotti v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2017 FC 71 (CanLII)
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






