Ø
Introduction
The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of two H&C
applications by sisters who had been excluded from the family class because
their mother had not declared them in her own permanent residence application.
The Court overturned the decisions because the officer
failed to consider how the continued separation from the sisters would affect
their mother emotionally and, in turn, affect the ability of their two young
half-brothers to receive care from her.
Ø
Key Principle
An H&C assessment involving children must consider the best
interests of all affected children and the relevant circumstances affecting
those interests.
An officer cannot simply identify the children’s best
interests and then assess them in isolation. Where family separation may affect
a parent’s emotional ability to care for other children, that impact can be
relevant to the best-interests analysis and must be meaningfully considered.
Ø
Background
The applicants were Ghanaian sisters whose mother had become
a Canadian citizen. They were excluded from the family class under paragraph
117(9)(d) because their mother had not declared them when she applied for
permanent residence.
The sisters sought H&C relief. At the time of their
applications, one was 15 and the other 21, while their Canadian half-brothers
were only 3 and 5 years old.
A previous Federal Court decision had already found that an
earlier officer failed to properly assess the best interests of the children.
On redetermination, the officer considered the interests of the sisters and
their half-brothers but again refused the H&C applications.
Ø
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the officer’s assessment was
unreasonable.
The officer concluded that it was in the best interests of
the two young boys to remain separated from their sisters, partly because their
mother might work more if the sisters came to Canada. However, the officer failed
to consider how the continued separation from her daughters would affect the
mother emotionally and how that emotional impact could affect her ability to
care for the boys.
The Court noted that this issue had been expressly raised in
the submissions and evidence before the officer. A general statement that the
emotional hardship of all parties had been considered was not enough because
the decision contained no actual analysis of the mother’s emotional hardship or
its potential effect on the boys.
The Court emphasized that the officer could ultimately have
concluded that this factor did not justify H&C relief. However, the officer
was required to consider the factor before reaching that conclusion.
Because this omission affected the best-interests
assessment, the decision was unreasonable.
Ø
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed the applications for judicial
review and returned both H&C applications to another officer for
redetermination.
Case Citation:
Fremah v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2016 FC 840 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






