The Federal Court dismissed
judicial review of a refusal of an LMIA-supported work permit for a long-haul
truck driver. The officer was not satisfied that the Applicant could adequately
perform the proposed work because his IELTS reading score of 5.0 was
insufficient for duties requiring him to read road signs, understand safety
procedures and regulations, record cargo information, and administer bills. The
Court found the language assessment reasonable. Pasted text
Key Principle
A visa officer may independently
assess whether an applicant’s language ability is sufficient to perform the
duties of the proposed occupation, even where the LMIA establishes language
requirements. The officer is not necessarily restricted to the employer’s
stated language requirements where additional language ability is relevant to
performing the job safely and effectively. Pasted text
Background
The Applicant, a citizen of
India, had approximately seven years of experience as a truck driver in Dubai.
He obtained an IELTS overall score of 5.5, with scores of 6.0 in listening, 5.0
in reading, 5.0 in writing and 6.0 in speaking. A Canadian employer obtained a
positive LMIA for Long Haul Truck Driver positions, with English verbal and
written language requirements, and subsequently offered the Applicant
employment. Pasted text
The officer refused the work
permit under IRPR 200(3)(a), finding that the Applicant had not demonstrated
that he could adequately perform the proposed work. The officer focused on the
IELTS reading score of 5.0 and concluded that the Applicant’s stated level of
English could create serious safety consequences given the need to understand
road signs, safety procedures and regulations and to complete required
documentation. Pasted text
Court Findings
• Correct program applied:
Although the refusal letter mistakenly stated that the application had been
assessed under the International Mobility Program, the GCMS notes identified
the application as an LMIA-supported work permit and relied on IRPR 200(3)(a),
which applied to the application. The Court therefore found the program
reference to be a typographical error rather than a substantive error. Pasted
text
• Officer could assess
language independently: The Court confirmed that an officer may determine
that an applicant requires language ability beyond the requirements stated in
the LMO/LMIA and job offer if that ability is relevant to performing the job
duties. Pasted text
• Reading proficiency was
relevant: The officer reasonably considered the Applicant’s reading ability
because truck-driving duties involve reading road signs, manuals, safety
procedures, regulations and transportation documentation. The Court relied on Patel
v. Canada, 2021 FC 573, where an IELTS reading score was similarly assessed
in relation to the duties of a long-haul truck driver. Pasted text
• No reweighing of IELTS
results: The Applicant argued that his listening, writing and speaking
scores demonstrated sufficient overall language ability. The Court found this
essentially invited it to reweigh the evidence, which is not the role of the
reviewing court on judicial review. Pasted text
• Applicant’s own evidence
mattered: The Applicant had identified the British Council’s explanation of
his IELTS results in his application. The officer therefore reasonably relied
on that description when assessing the significance of the 5.0 reading score.
Pasted text
Outcome
The Court dismissed the
application for judicial review and upheld the work permit refusal. No question
was certified.
Case
Citation:
Singh v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2023 FC 170 (CanLII)
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian
Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






