The Federal Court reviewed the
refusal of an Albanian couple’s application for permanent residence on
humanitarian and compassionate (H&C) grounds.
The Court overturned the refusal
because the immigration officer improperly discounted the family’s
establishment in Canada and failed to give them an opportunity to address
concerns about relocating elsewhere within Albania.
Key Principle
Under subsection 25(1) of the
Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), immigration officers must
meaningfully assess an applicant’s establishment in Canada and the hardship
associated with leaving.
An officer cannot simply
dismiss employment, community involvement and other establishment evidence as
normal or expected without explaining why it carries insufficient weight.
Furthermore, although an H&C
officer may consider whether relocation within an applicant’s home country
could reduce hardship, procedural fairness may require an opportunity to
respond when the officer introduces a relocation option that the applicants had
not addressed.
Background
Marsela and Edmond Baco, Albanian
citizens, arrived in Canada in May 2012 and unsuccessfully claimed refugee
protection.
Following previous H&C
refusals, their application was reconsidered by another officer in October
2016.
They relied on their employment,
community relationships, the best interests of their two Canadian-born children
and hardship arising from an alleged blood feud between their family and the
Pango family.
The officer acknowledged their
establishment but considered it no greater than normally expected.
The officer also concluded that
the family could safely relocate to Fier, Albania, where relatives resided, and
refused the application.
Court Findings
The Federal Court identified two
significant errors.
First, the officer
unreasonably assessed the applicants’ establishment in Canada.
The officer discounted their
achievements because they represented an expected level of integration, without
explaining what degree of establishment would have been sufficient.
The Court emphasized that
officers must assess applicants’ actual accomplishments and consider how
disrupting their established lives would affect them.
Simply acknowledging employment
and community relationships was insufficient.
Second, the officer breached
procedural fairness by introducing an internal relocation option without
notice.
The applicants had not addressed
relocation to Fier in their H&C submissions, and the issue had not arisen
during their refugee proceedings.
The Court clarified that
refugee-specific relocation principles do not automatically apply to H&C
applications.
Nevertheless, because the officer
relied on relocation to minimize the family’s hardship, fairness required an
opportunity to explain why that option might not be viable.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed
judicial review, set aside the refusal and returned the application to a
different immigration officer for reconsideration.
No question of general importance
was certified.
Case
Citation:
Baco v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2017 FC 694 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






