The Federal Court reviewed a
decision of the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD) dismissing a permanent
resident’s appeal concerning his failure to meet Canada’s residency
obligations.
The Court upheld the decision
because the applicant’s employment with a Canadian company in China did not
qualify as an overseas assignment under the applicable immigration regulations.
The Court also rejected his
argument that the IAD breached procedural fairness by proceeding with the
hearing despite his representatives’ incompetence.
Key Principle
Under section 28 of the
Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), permanent residents must
generally accumulate at least 730 qualifying days within a five-year period.
Certain periods of employment
abroad for a Canadian business may count toward this requirement under
subsection 61(3) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR).
Working abroad for a Canadian
company does not automatically satisfy the residency obligation. The employment
must meet the regulatory requirements for an overseas assignment.
Additionally, ineffective
representation does not automatically establish procedural unfairness. An
applicant must demonstrate serious incompetence resulting in a miscarriage of
justice.
Background
Jun Tao Bi, a Chinese
citizen, became a Canadian permanent resident in September 2005.
Approximately one month
later, he returned to China.
In February 2007, he began
working as an assistant general manager for a Canadian business in China under
a contract lasting approximately three years.
In April 2010, he applied for
a permanent resident travel document, reporting only 130 days of physical
presence in Canada during the preceding four-and-a-half years.
His application was refused
because he had not established compliance with the residency obligation.
The IAD dismissed his appeal,
concluding that his overseas employment did not qualify under subsection 61(3).
Court Findings
The Federal Court upheld the
IAD’s reasoning.
First, the applicant was
hired to work abroad rather than temporarily assigned overseas.
Although prior employment in
Canada was not mandatory, the evidence did not establish a temporary assignment
connected to anticipated employment in Canada.
Second, there was
insufficient evidence of continued employment in Canada.
Mr. Bi had not demonstrated
that his employer agreed to employ him in Canada following his overseas
contract.
Third, the IAD did not breach
procedural fairness by refusing an adjournment.
The Court acknowledged that
his two representatives lacked adequate training and understanding of the
proceedings.
However, Mr. Bi failed to
establish that their incompetence caused a miscarriage of justice or that
competent representation would have created a reasonable probability of a
different outcome.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed
judicial review and upheld the IAD’s decision concerning the applicant’s
residency obligation.
The decision emphasizes the
importance of documenting a qualifying overseas assignment and maintaining
evidence of the employment relationship with the Canadian business.
It also illustrates that
allegations of incompetent representation require proof of resulting prejudice.
No question of general
importance was certified.
Case
Citation:
Bi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 293, [2013] 4 FCR 277 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






