The Federal Court reviewed a
removal order against a Nigerian permanent resident who allegedly failed to
meet Canada’s residency obligation.
The Court allowed judicial review
because the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD) failed to adequately consider the
best interests of her Canadian-born daughter when assessing humanitarian and
compassionate (H&C) considerations.
Key Principle
Under section 28 of the
Immigration and Refugee Protection Act (IRPA), permanent residents must
generally accumulate at least 730 qualifying days within a five-year period.
Where an applicant fails to meet
this requirement, H&C considerations may justify retaining permanent
resident status.
Immigration decision-makers
must meaningfully assess the best interests of affected children, even when
evidence supporting the H&C request is limited.
Simply acknowledging a child’s
citizenship or suggesting that the child can return to Canada later is
insufficient without an individualized assessment.
Background
Adanneya Uga Iroha, a Nigerian
citizen, became a Canadian permanent resident in June 2008 through spousal
sponsorship.
In June 2013, immigration
authorities questioned her Canadian residency history when she returned from
Nigeria.
An officer determined that she
had failed to satisfy the 730-day residency obligation and issued a departure
order.
Ms. Iroha appealed, relying on
her claimed residence in Canada, employment history, family circumstances and
H&C considerations.
In January 2017, the IAD
dismissed her appeal, finding insufficient evidence of qualifying residence or
circumstances justifying relief.
Court Findings
The Federal Court examined the
IAD’s credibility assessment, refusal to postpone the hearing and consideration
of H&C factors.
The Court found that the IAD was
entitled to refuse the postponement and that its member had not demonstrated
bias.
It also accepted that passport
stamps alone could not establish physical presence in Canada and that the
applicant’s supporting documents were insufficient to overturn the IAD’s
residency findings.
However, the IAD’s assessment
of the child’s best interests was unreasonable.
The IAD had concluded that the
child should remain with both parents and could return to Canada later because
she was a Canadian citizen.
The Court held that this
reasoning failed to adequately examine the child’s individual circumstances and
the consequences of living in Nigeria.
Relying on Kanthasamy v.
Canada, 2015 SCC 61, the Court emphasized that children’s interests must
receive careful, specific and meaningful consideration.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed
judicial review and returned the case to a different IAD panel for
reconsideration.
The Court did not determine that
Ms. Iroha satisfied the residency requirement or automatically grant H&C
relief.
No question of general importance
was certified.
Case
Citation:
Iroha v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2017 FC 785 CanLII
Written by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






