The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a Mexican family’s
application for permanent residence on humanitarian and compassionate grounds.
The parents had lived in Canada for several years with their
children and argued that removal to Mexico would negatively affect the children
because of their established lives in Canada and concerns about crime, poverty,
and discrimination.
The Court overturned the refusal because the officer did not
properly identify and assess what was actually in the children’s best
interests.
Key Principle
A best-interests-of-the-child assessment is not simply a
test of whether the child would suffer enough hardship if removed from Canada.
The officer must first genuinely consider what outcome is
in the child’s best interests, including the child’s current circumstances
in Canada, and then weigh that factor with the other H&C considerations.
An officer should not reduce the analysis to whether the
child can obtain basic education, health care, or protection in the country of
return.
Background
The applicants were a married couple from Mexico and their
son. Their daughter, who was born in Canada, was a Canadian citizen.
The family came to Canada in 2005 and remained after their
authorized stay expired.
They later made refugee claims based on a fear of abduction
in Mexico, but those claims were refused. A subsequent Pre-Removal Risk
Assessment was also unsuccessful.
The family then relied on H&C considerations, including
their establishment in Canada, conditions in Mexico, and the best interests of
their children.
The officer acknowledged that the children were doing well
in school and that their best interests were an important factor. However, the
officer concluded that the children were young enough to adapt to Mexico and
had not shown that relocation would cause a sufficiently significant negative
impact.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the officer’s best-interests
analysis was unreasonable.
The officer did not meaningfully consider whether remaining
in Canada with their parents and maintaining their existing lives would be in
the children’s best interests.
Instead, the officer focused primarily on whether the
children would face sufficiently serious negative consequences in Mexico.
The Court emphasized that immigration officers must be “alert,
alive and sensitive” to the interests of affected children and examine
those interests with care.
The officer acknowledged evidence that children in Mexico
were affected by high levels of crime and violence, but then discounted those
concerns because the applicants had not shown that their particular children
would be specifically targeted.
The Court found that this failed to properly assess the
risks from the children’s perspective.
The Court was also concerned by the officer’s repeated use
of expressions such as “significant negative impact” and the conclusion
that the children’s interests had not been negatively affected enough to
warrant an exemption.
This approach effectively introduced a hardship threshold
into the best-interests analysis.
The Court explained that there is no minimum level of
hardship that a child must experience before their best interests become
relevant. The proper question is what is actually in the child’s best interests
and how much weight those interests should receive in the overall H&C
assessment.
Because this error was sufficient to decide the case, the
Court found it unnecessary to determine whether the officer had also improperly
assessed the family’s establishment in Canada.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed the application for judicial
review and returned the H&C application to a different immigration
officer for redetermination.
Historical Note: This decision was issued before the Supreme Court of
Canada’s decision in Kanthasamy v. Canada, 2015 SCC 61. The broader
H&C framework in force at the time therefore differed from the current
approach, although the requirement to give meaningful consideration to the best
interests of affected children remains important.
Case Citation:
Jimenez v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 527 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian
Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






