The Federal Court reviewed an immigration officer’s refusal
to issue a permanent resident (PR) card to an applicant whose renewal
application had already been processed.
The Court overturned the refusal because the officer
improperly withheld the card after conducting a new residency obligation
assessment at the time of collection, rather than applying the statutory
requirements governing PR card issuance.
Key Principle
Under section 28 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection
Act (IRPA), permanent residents generally must satisfy a residency obligation
of at least 730 days within every five-year period.
However, the issuance of a PR card is governed by separate
requirements under subsection 59(1) of the Immigration and Refugee Protection
Regulations (IRPR).
An immigration officer cannot withhold a PR card solely
because a new residency assessment raises concerns about compliance, where the
applicant has satisfied the statutory conditions for card issuance and has not
legally lost PR status.
Background
Faisal Nawaz Khan was a Canadian permanent resident whose PR
card expired in March 2010.
He signed his renewal application in April 2010, and
immigration authorities received it on June 8, 2010.
His application indicated that he had been absent from
Canada for 1,044 days during the relevant five-year period, within the
permitted absence limit.
The Case Processing Centre assessed his application and
prepared a new PR card in December 2010.
Mr. Khan was invited to collect the card but was in Pakistan
and could not attend the initial appointment.
When he attended the Toronto immigration office on June 28,
2011, the officer reassessed his absences over the five years immediately
preceding that date.
The officer calculated 1,309 days of absence and refused to
provide the card, referring the matter for investigation.
Mr. Khan challenged the decision through judicial review.
Court Findings
First, the PR card had been processed but not yet legally
issued.
The Court rejected the argument that the officer was functus
officio, explaining that issuance required actual delivery of the card.
Second, the officer applied the wrong approach to the
residency assessment.
The relevant assessment period for the renewal application
ended when immigration authorities received the application, not when the
applicant attended to collect the card.
Third, PR card issuance and residency obligation compliance
are distinct legal matters.
The Court held that subsection 59(1) did not authorize
withholding the card merely because the officer wished to conduct a fresh
residency assessment.
Fourth, the applicant had satisfied the applicable issuance
requirements.
The record indicated that the necessary documentation had
been submitted. The officer’s remaining responsibility was to verify the
original documents against the copies previously provided.
Fifth, immigration authorities retained the power to
investigate residency compliance.
The Court clarified that issuing the PR card did not prevent
a separate investigation or subsequent proceedings concerning a possible breach
of the residency obligation.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed judicial review and set aside the
refusal to issue the PR card.
The Court ordered immigration authorities to arrange
delivery of the card for collection in Canada or Pakistan, depending on Mr.
Khan’s location, subject to verification of his original documents and
surrender of his expired card.
The Court also awarded Mr. Khan $5,000 in costs.
The decision confirms that PR status and possession of a
valid PR card are legally distinct. Immigration authorities must follow the
prescribed issuance requirements and cannot substitute an improperly conducted
residency assessment for those requirements.
No question of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
Khan v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 1471 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian
Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






