The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a skilled worker
permanent residence application based on the medical inadmissibility of the
applicant’s adult son.
The son had been diagnosed with borderline intellectual
functioning, and immigration authorities concluded that he would create an
excessive demand on Canadian social services.
The Court overturned the refusal because the officer did not
properly assess the family’s detailed plan to privately cover the son’s care.
Key Principle
Medical inadmissibility based on excessive demand requires
an individualized assessment.
It is not enough to show that a person may technically be
eligible for publicly funded services. The decision-maker must assess whether,
based on the family’s actual circumstances and care plan, the person is
reasonably likely to use those services.
Background
The applicant had originally applied for permanent residence
in 2004.
His application was refused because of concerns that his
son’s condition would create an excessive demand on social services.
After an earlier judicial review was settled, the
application was reassessed and the family submitted a detailed care plan
addressing the son’s anticipated needs and expenses.
The family estimated annual care costs of approximately
$12,840 and proposed covering those costs through employment income, savings,
investment properties, and financial commitments from relatives.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found an important contradiction in the
medical assessment.
The medical officer accepted that, if the family followed
its proposed care plan, the costs would fall below the excessive-demand
threshold.
Despite that finding, the application was still refused
because the son could potentially qualify for publicly funded programs such as
the Ontario Disability Support Program.
The Court found this unreasonable.
The proper question was not simply whether the son could
access public services, but whether he would actually be likely to need or use
them.
The evidence showed substantial financial resources and a
detailed plan for privately funding the son’s needs. The officer nevertheless
appeared to assume that the plan would not be followed without explaining why.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed the application for judicial
review and returned the matter to a different visa officer for
redetermination.
The case confirms that medical inadmissibility cannot be
based merely on theoretical eligibility for public services. Immigration
officers must realistically assess the applicant’s personal circumstances,
financial resources, and proposed plan for meeting anticipated care needs.
Case Citation:
Majeed v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 1204 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






