The Federal Court considered a mandamus application brought
by 63 applicants whose permanent residence applications under the Quebec
Investor Program had remained undecided for several years.
The Court refused to order the Minister to make decisions
within a specified timeframe because the applicants had not established that
the delay was unreasonable in the circumstances.
Key
Principle
There is no fixed period of delay that automatically
establishes entitlement to mandamus.
Whether an immigration processing delay is unreasonable must
be determined based on the particular circumstances, including the nature of
the application, the reasons for the delay, whether the applicants contributed
to the delay and whether the government has provided a satisfactory
justification.
The Court must also consider the effect of mandamus on other
applicants waiting in the processing queue. Granting an order that effectively
allows one applicant to jump the queue may be inequitable.
Background
The 63 applicants had been selected by Quebec under the
Investor Program and had each made the required $400,000 investment
before submitting their permanent residence applications.
Their applications were submitted through the Canadian
Embassy in Damascus between 2010 and 2011.
The Damascus embassy closed in January 2012 because of the
civil conflict in Syria. Approximately 22,000 permanent residence files were
transferred to the Canadian visa office in Ankara, including thousands
requiring adjudication.
The Tehran visa office subsequently closed as well,
resulting in the transfer of approximately 50,000 temporary resident files to
Ankara.
The increased workload caused significant processing delays.
The applicants had not received decisions on their permanent residence
applications and therefore sought mandamus requiring the Minister to make final
decisions within a specified period.
Court Findings
The Federal Court applied the established Apotex test
for mandamus and focused particularly on whether a reasonable period had passed
without a satisfactory explanation for the delay.
The Court emphasized that the concept of a “reasonable time”
cannot be determined by applying a fixed number of months or years to every
immigration application. The circumstances surrounding the particular
applications must be considered.
The government provided a satisfactory explanation for the
delay. The closure of the Damascus and Tehran offices had resulted in an
extraordinary increase in the Ankara office’s workload. The government had also
hired 17 additional staff members, more than doubling the office’s
previous staffing level.
The Court found that the government’s response demonstrated
good faith efforts to address the increased workload. The processing of
applications also had to be understood within the broader immigration system,
where resources could be allocated differently among various immigration
categories depending on government priorities and circumstances.
The applicants argued that they had suffered significant
financial prejudice because their $400,000 investments had remained frozen
while their applications were pending. The Court recognized the circumstances
but found that this did not establish that the delay was unreasonable.
The Court also considered the effect of granting mandamus on
other applicants. The evidence showed that hundreds of applications were ahead
of the applicants in the processing queue. Granting mandamus in their favour
would effectively give them priority over other applicants who had filed
earlier.
The Court therefore concluded that the applicants had not
demonstrated an unreasonable delay or satisfied the requirements necessary for
mandamus.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the applications for judicial
review and refused to issue an order of mandamus requiring the Minister to
decide the applicants’ Quebec Investor applications within a specified
timeframe.
Case Citation:
Mazarei v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2014 FC 322 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






