The Federal Court considered whether visa officers breached
procedural fairness by refusing Federal Skilled Worker applications after
applicants failed to provide documents requested by email.
The Court upheld the refusals because the Minister
established that the emails requesting the documents had been properly sent to
the applicants’ authorized representative.
Key Principle
Where an immigration office proves on a balance of
probabilities that an email was properly sent to the address provided by
the applicant or representative, a rebuttable presumption arises that the
communication was received.
The mere assertion that an email was not received is
generally insufficient to rebut that presumption.
The risk associated with a communication failure may fall on
the applicant once the Minister establishes that the email was properly sent
and there is no evidence that it bounced back or otherwise failed.
Background
The applicants, Priteshkumar Patel and Jayshree Bhatty,
were Indian citizens represented by the same immigration consultant.
The visa officers emailed the consultant requesting
additional documents, including passports, medical information and payment of
the right of permanent residence fees. The applicants were given 45 days
to provide the requested information.
The emails were recorded in the visa office’s systems, and
copies appeared in the sender’s sent folder. The applicants’ consultant
maintained that neither he nor his clients had received the emails.
The requested documents were not provided, and the officers
subsequently refused the permanent residence applications because the
information requested had not been received.
Mr. Bhatty requested reconsideration after learning of the
refusal, while Mr. Patel did not request reconsideration.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the visa office had established
that the emails were properly sent.
The evidence showed that the messages were sent to the correct
email address, copies appeared in the visa office’s sent folder and there
was no indication that the emails had bounced back or otherwise failed to
transmit.
The Court distinguished earlier cases where lost emails had
resulted in judicial review being allowed. In those cases, the files had been
transferred between visa offices and the applicants had not previously
communicated successfully with the new office. Here, there had been previous
successful email communications between the visa office and the same
consultant.
The Court therefore found no breach of procedural fairness.
However, the Court noted that the result was potentially
harsh. Once the consultant learned that the applications had been refused
because of an email he said he never received, the Court considered it
important that immigration authorities remain sensitive to fairness and equity.
The Court referred to the possibility of reconsideration where an applicant is
not at fault, particularly to avoid requiring the applicant to submit an
entirely new application and pay another processing fee.
In these cases, however, the refusal to reconsider was not
itself challenged before the Court.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed both applications for
judicial review and upheld the permanent residence refusals.
Case Citation:
Patel v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2014 FC 856 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






