The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a Federal Skilled
Worker permanent residence application involving an Indian citizen who claimed
additional adaptability points based on relatives living in Canada.
The Court upheld the refusal because the applicant failed to
provide sufficient documentary evidence establishing his family relationships
and the relatives’ residence in Canada.
Key Principle
Under sections 76 and 83 of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Regulations (IRPR), Federal Skilled Worker applicants may receive
adaptability points for qualifying relatives who are Canadian citizens or
permanent residents residing in Canada.
The burden rests on applicants to establish both the
qualifying family relationship and the relative’s residence in Canada through
sufficient supporting evidence.
Immigration officers are not ordinarily required to request
additional documents or provide an opportunity to correct deficiencies that
arise directly from published application requirements.
Background
Gurinder Singh, an Indian citizen residing in Australia,
applied for permanent residence under the Federal Skilled Worker Class as a
cook.
His wife, Amanpreet Kaur, was included in the application.
Mr. Singh claimed five adaptability points based on his
maternal grandparents and maternal uncle, who allegedly resided together in
Surrey, British Columbia.
He submitted an affidavit signed by the relatives, copies of
his grandparents’ permanent resident cards and his uncle’s Canadian passport.
However, he did not provide birth certificates or other
documents establishing the claimed family relationships.
The immigration officer awarded Mr. Singh 62 points, below
the required minimum of 67.
The application was refused because the officer awarded no
adaptability points for the claimed Canadian relatives.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found no reviewable error in the officer’s
decision.
First, the applicant failed to establish the qualifying
family relationships.
The permanent resident cards and Canadian passport
established immigration status but did not demonstrate how the individuals were
related to Mr. Singh.
Second, the affidavit lacked sufficient corroboration.
The Court accepted that an affidavit from interested family
members may receive limited evidentiary weight when unsupported by independent
documentation.
Third, the applicant failed to establish the relatives’
residence in Canada.
The submitted documents did not adequately demonstrate that
the relatives were living in Canada.
Fourth, the officer provided adequate reasons.
The refusal identified the missing relationship
documentation, including birth certificates, and explained why adaptability
points were not awarded.
Fifth, procedural fairness did not require further
inquiries.
The application checklist clearly identified the required
evidence. Because the officer’s concerns involved insufficient documentation
rather than doubts about its authenticity, there was no obligation to request
additional information or conduct an interview.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed judicial review and upheld the
permanent residence refusal.
The decision confirms that immigration applicants must
substantiate claims for adaptability points with reliable documentary evidence.
Affidavits and proof of immigration status alone may be insufficient to
establish qualifying family relationships and residence in Canada.
The Court also declined to award costs because no special
reasons justified doing so.
No question of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
Singh v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 855 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian
Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






