The Federal Court reviewed the dismissal of a permanent
resident’s appeal concerning his failure to meet Canada’s residency obligation
while working abroad for a Canadian company.
Although the Court upheld the finding that his overseas
employment did not satisfy the residency requirements, it overturned the
decision because the Immigration Appeal Division (IAD) incorrectly identified
his minor daughter as an adult and failed to consider her best interests.
Key Principle
Under subsection 28(2) of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Act (IRPA), permanent residents must satisfy the 730-day residency
obligation within the applicable five-year period.
Certain periods of overseas employment for a Canadian
business may qualify, subject to the requirements of subsection 61(3) of the
Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR).
When considering humanitarian and compassionate (H&C)
relief from a residency obligation breach, decision-makers must identify and
meaningfully assess the best interests of any minor child directly affected by
the decision.
Background
Dong Sheng Wei, a Chinese citizen, became a Canadian
permanent resident in May 1999.
In August 2004, he began working in China for Immunechem
Pharmaceuticals Inc., a Canadian company based in British Columbia.
His responsibilities included coordinating research
projects, supervising production activities and maintaining business
relationships in China.
Although he worked for a Canadian company and maintained
employment connections with Canada, he spent only 116 days physically present
in Canada between May 2004 and May 2009.
His application for a permanent resident travel document was
refused for failing to satisfy the residency obligation.
The IAD dismissed his appeal, finding that his overseas
employment did not qualify as an assignment under the regulations and that
insufficient H&C considerations justified relief.
Court Findings
First, the overseas employment did not qualify toward the
residency obligation.
The Court accepted that the applicant was employed by a
legitimate Canadian business. However, his position existed exclusively in
China, with no Canadian position available for him to return to after the
assignment.
Second, maintaining employment connections with Canada was
insufficient.
Although the applicant received Canadian remuneration, paid
Canadian taxes and maintained regular contact with his employer, the Court
found the IAD’s interpretation consistent with the applicable jurisprudence.
Third, the IAD incorrectly identified the applicant’s
daughter as an adult.
The documentary evidence established that his daughter, Amy
Wei, was born on February 16, 1999, making her a minor when the appeal was
heard.
Fourth, the IAD failed to consider the child’s best
interests.
The tribunal incorrectly concluded that no minor child
required consideration, despite having received documentation identifying the
daughter and a letter describing her relationship with her father.
Fifth, this evidentiary error made the H&C assessment
unreasonable.
The Court found that the tribunal ignored important evidence
directly relevant to whether special relief should be granted.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed judicial review and returned the
matter to a differently constituted IAD panel for redetermination.
The decision confirms that even where a PR has breached the
residency obligation, the IAD must properly consider H&C factors,
particularly the best interests of minor children affected by the potential
loss of PR status.
The Court did not find that the applicant satisfied his
residency obligation or automatically qualified for H&C relief.
No question of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
Wei v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 1084 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






