The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a humanitarian and
compassionate (H&C) permanent residence application submitted by an
elderly, blind British citizen who had established significant personal and
community ties in Canada.
The Court overturned the refusal because the immigration
officer failed to properly consider the applicant’s sworn evidence that he had
no remaining family, friends or support network in the United Kingdom.
Key Principle
Under subsection 25(1) of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Act (IRPA), immigration officers may grant humanitarian and
compassionate relief where an applicant’s circumstances justify an exemption
from ordinary immigration requirements.
An officer cannot dismiss relevant sworn evidence as
insufficient without a reasonable explanation, particularly where that evidence
directly supports the applicant’s claimed hardship.
The Court relied on Maldonado v. Canada, which
establishes a presumption of truthfulness for sworn testimony in the absence of
valid reasons to doubt its accuracy.
Background
Michael Gordon Westmore, a 70-year-old British citizen, had
maintained strong ties to Toronto through his long-term relationship with his
husband, Stennett.
The couple had been together since the 1980s and married in
2003. They initiated a spousal sponsorship application in 2004, but Stennett
died before it was completed.
Mr. Westmore subsequently requested H&C consideration
and received approval in principle in August 2005.
However, his application was refused in March 2008 after he
failed to submit updated medical information.
In November 2009, he submitted another H&C application,
relying on his establishment in Canada, blindness, connection to the Canadian
National Institute for the Blind (CNIB), and lack of family or friends in the
United Kingdom.
The immigration officer refused the application in September
2011, concluding that insufficient hardship had been established.
Court Findings
First, the officer failed to properly consider sworn
evidence.
Mr. Westmore expressly declared in his application documents
that he had no remaining family or friends in the United Kingdom and that his
support network was entirely in Canada.
Second, the officer unreasonably questioned the absence of
support abroad.
Despite these sworn declarations, the officer concluded that
insufficient evidence had been provided concerning potential family members or
friends in the United Kingdom.
Third, the officer failed to explain why the declarations
were insufficient.
The Court found no contradictory evidence or adequate
explanation justifying the officer’s rejection of the applicant’s statements.
Fourth, the previous H&C approval was not binding.
The Court accepted that the officer could reasonably reach a
different conclusion from the earlier positive assessment, particularly because
the applicant had not completed the previous process and had continued
maintaining visitor status.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed judicial review, set aside the
H&C refusal and returned the application to a different immigration officer
for reconsideration.
The decision confirms that sworn statements concerning the
absence of family or support networks in an applicant’s home country must
receive meaningful consideration. Officers cannot disregard such evidence
without providing a reasonable justification.
The Court did not directly approve permanent residence.
No question of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
Westmore v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 1023 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






