The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a Federal Skilled
Worker (FSW) permanent residence application under NOC 0711, Construction
Managers.
The Court overturned the refusal because the immigration
officer relied on concerns arising from an independent internet search
regarding the applicant’s employer without providing him an opportunity to
respond.
Key Principle
Immigration applicants bear the responsibility of providing
sufficient evidence to establish that their employment satisfies the applicable
National Occupational Classification (NOC) requirements.
Officers generally have no obligation to request additional
documents where an application contains insufficient evidence of qualifying
work experience.
However, where an officer independently obtains
information that raises concerns about the authenticity or credibility of an
applicant’s employment evidence, procedural fairness requires an opportunity to
address those concerns.
A breach of procedural fairness will generally invalidate
the resulting decision, even where other grounds for refusal may exist.
Background
The applicant, an Iranian citizen, applied for permanent
residence in April 2010 under NOC 0711, Construction Managers.
He claimed employment with Abadi-O-Tarh-O-Tadbir Consulting
Engineers Co. Ltd.
His supporting documents included employment reference
letters and official Iranian Gazette records concerning the company’s
incorporation and corporate resolutions.
The officer refused the application, concluding that the
employment documentation did not sufficiently demonstrate the required NOC
duties.
However, the GCMS notes revealed an additional concern: the
officer had conducted an internet search and found no records of the
applicant’s employer.
The applicant was neither interviewed nor informed of this
concern before refusal.
Court Findings
The Federal Court distinguished concerns about insufficient
employment evidence from concerns about an employer’s authenticity.
The Court accepted that the officer was not required to
request further clarification regarding the applicant’s job duties.
However, the independent internet search raised doubts about
whether the employer genuinely existed.
Because these concerns were not disclosed, the applicant had
no opportunity to provide an explanation or additional supporting evidence.
The Court rejected the Minister’s argument that the
procedural fairness breach was irrelevant because the officer had also
identified deficiencies in the employment documentation.
The GCMS notes indicated that the internet search formed
part of the officer’s reasoning, and its influence on the overall assessment
could not be determined.
The Court emphasized that procedural fairness is an
independent legal requirement. A decision should not ordinarily be upheld
merely because the applicant might ultimately receive another refusal.
Outcome
The Federal Court allowed judicial review and returned the
application to a different immigration officer for redetermination. No question
of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
Zahedi v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2013 FC 931 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






