The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a permanent
resident travel document application by a permanent resident who had previously
been informed that his renewed PR card was available for collection.
The Court upheld the refusal because the earlier PR card
renewal process did not prevent the visa officer from independently assessing
the applicant’s residency obligation when he later applied for a travel
document from outside Canada.
Key Principle
A decision concerning a PR card renewal does not prevent
a visa officer from independently assessing compliance with the residency
obligation in a subsequent travel document application.
A PR card renewal and a permanent resident travel document
are separate processes, and the relevant residency periods may be different.
A permanent resident outside Canada who does not possess a
valid PR card is not entitled to the presumption of permanent resident status
under section 31(2) of the IRPA. Before issuing a travel document, the officer
must determine whether one of the statutory conditions under section 31(3) has
been met.
Background
The applicant was a Libyan citizen who became a permanent
resident of Canada in December 2000.
In January 2009, he applied to renew his permanent resident
card. His application was approved and, in March 2009, he was informed that his
renewed PR card was available for collection, subject to an appointment where
his eligibility could be reviewed.
Before collecting the card, the applicant travelled to
Libya. While outside Canada, he applied for a permanent resident travel
document so that he could return to Canada.
The visa office requested additional evidence concerning his
Canadian residency, including employment documents, tax notices of assessment
and rental agreements. The applicant did not provide the requested documents.
His travel document application was refused because he had
not established compliance with the residency obligation. The IAD later
reviewed the matter and found that the applicant had demonstrated only 118
days of physical presence in Canada during the relevant five-year period,
rather than the required 730 days.
Court Findings
The Federal Court rejected the applicant’s argument that the
visa officer was bound by the earlier PR card renewal decision.
The Court found that the March 2009 letter did not
constitute a final determination that the applicant was entitled to a renewed
PR card. The approval remained subject to an assessment of his eligibility when
he attended to collect the card.
The Court also explained that the PR card renewal and
travel document applications are separate processes. The residency periods
assessed in the two applications can differ, and the applicant’s status at the
time of the travel document application must be assessed independently.
Importantly, the applicant did not possess a valid PR card
when he applied for the travel document from outside Canada. As a result, he
was not entitled to the statutory presumption of permanent resident status
under section 31(2) of the IRPA.
The Court also found that the applicant did not satisfy any
of the conditions under section 31(3) that would require the issuance of a
travel document. He had not established compliance with the residency
obligation, had not previously obtained an H&C determination overcoming the
breach, and had not satisfied the second requirement concerning an appealable
residency determination.
The Court rejected the applicant’s argument that the IAD had
ignored his evidence. The IAD is presumed to have considered the evidence
before it and is not required to refer to every piece of evidence in its
reasons.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review and upheld the refusal of the permanent resident travel document.
Case Citation:
Tantoush v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2014 FC 245 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






