The Federal Court of Appeal considered whether a child born
outside Canada through assisted human reproduction could acquire Canadian
citizenship by descent under paragraph 3(1)(b) of the Citizenship Act
where the Canadian parent had no genetic connection to the child.
The majority of the Court held that a genetic link was
required for derivative citizenship under paragraph 3(1)(b). The Federal
Court’s decision granting citizenship was therefore set aside.
Key Principle
For citizenship by descent under paragraph 3(1)(b) of the
Citizenship Act, the Canadian parent must have the required genetic
connection to the child.
The provision concerns citizenship that arises automatically
by operation of law at birth. It is therefore distinct from section 5.1,
which provides a separate process for citizenship for children adopted by
Canadian citizens.
A legal parent-child relationship established under foreign
or Canadian family law does not, by itself, allow a person with no genetic
connection to transmit citizenship under paragraph 3(1)(b).
Background
The respondent was born in India in 2009. Her Canadian
father and her birth mother were married and were both listed as her parents on
her Indian birth certificate.
The child was conceived through in vitro fertilization
using sperm and eggs from anonymous donors. Neither the Canadian father nor the
birth mother had a genetic connection to the child.
The Canadian father applied for a Canadian citizenship
certificate for the child under paragraph 3(1)(b). The application was refused
after DNA testing confirmed that he was not genetically related to the child.
The Federal Court subsequently allowed the child’s
application for judicial review. It found that the term “parent” could include
a legally recognized parent even where there was no genetic connection.
The Minister appealed to the Federal Court of Appeal.
Court Findings
The majority of the Federal Court of Appeal disagreed with
the Federal Court.
The Court examined the wording of paragraph 3(1)(b),
including the French version of the provision, and concluded that the wording
contemplated a genetic or gestational connection between the child and the
Canadian parent.
The Court also considered the legislative history of the
Citizenship Act. It found that derivative citizenship under paragraph 3(1)(b)
is acquired automatically at the time of birth. Because citizenship
crystallizes at birth, the Court held that the relationship giving rise to
citizenship must exist at that time.
The Court distinguished this process from adoption under
section 5.1. Parliament had created a separate statutory mechanism through
which a foreign-born child adopted by a Canadian citizen could obtain
citizenship, subject to specified requirements.
The Court therefore concluded that the Canadian father,
having no genetic connection to the child, could not transmit citizenship under
paragraph 3(1)(b).
The Court also considered the citizenship policy concerning
assisted human reproduction and noted that the policy itself had no independent
legal force. Citizenship could only be granted if authorized by the Citizenship
Act.
Justice Mainville dissented. He concluded that “parent” in
paragraph 3(1)(b) referred to the legal concept of parenthood, rather
than exclusively to a biological or genetic parent. In his view, the child was
legally recognized as the Canadian father’s child under both Indian and
Canadian law and therefore acquired derivative citizenship.
Outcome
The majority allowed the Minister’s appeal, set aside
the Federal Court decision and dismissed the application for judicial review.
The child was therefore not entitled to Canadian citizenship by descent under
paragraph 3(1)(b) because the Canadian parent had no genetic connection to her.
Case Citation:
Kandola v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2014 FCA 85 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






