The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a permanent
residence application under the Saskatchewan Immigrant Nominee Program after
the applicant was found inadmissible for misrepresentation concerning his
claimed employment experience.
The Court upheld the decision because the officer reasonably
preferred the evidence obtained through an employment verification call over
the applicant’s later contradictory evidence and found that the applicant had
failed to provide a credible explanation for the discrepancy.
Key Principle
Where an officer identifies concerns about possible
misrepresentation and provides the applicant with a procedural fairness
letter, the applicant bears the responsibility of providing a credible and
complete response to those concerns.
An officer is not required to accept a response simply
because it consists of a sworn statement from the applicant or an employer. The
officer may assess the reliability of conflicting evidence and determine which
evidence should be given greater weight.
In a provincial nominee application, the federal immigration
officer remains responsible for determining admissibility, including
misrepresentation, even though the province has already nominated the
applicant.
Background
The applicant was an Indian citizen who applied to the
Saskatchewan Immigrant Nominee Program as a carpenter. Saskatchewan approved
his nomination, and he subsequently applied for permanent residence.
In support of his applications, the applicant provided
employment documents stating that he had worked as a carpenter for Panesar
Timber Store.
During a telephone verification conducted by the Canadian
High Commission, the person who identified himself as the proprietor of Panesar
Timber Store stated that the applicant had never worked for the company. He
also stated that the business only manufactured doors and door frames and
identified the employees working for the company, none of whom was the
applicant.
The officer subsequently sent the applicant a procedural
fairness letter outlining the concerns and giving him an opportunity to
respond.
The applicant responded with a sworn statement from the
purported employer, Jit Singh, denying that he had received the verification
call and confirming that the applicant had worked for the company as a
carpenter.
The officer was not satisfied with this explanation and
found the applicant inadmissible for misrepresentation under section 40(1)(a)
of the IRPA.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the officer’s decision was
reasonable.
The verification call had been made to the same telephone
number appearing on the employer’s documents. The person who answered
identified himself as Jit Singh, denied repeatedly that the applicant had ever
worked for him and provided details concerning the company’s employees and
business activities.
The Court found that the later explanation that another
unidentified person might have answered the telephone was unsupported and did
not provide a credible explanation for the contradictory information.
The applicant argued that the officer should have conducted
further inquiries or consulted Saskatchewan officials before making the
misrepresentation finding. The Court rejected this argument.
A copy of the procedural fairness letter had been provided
to Saskatchewan officials, and the applicant was given a clear opportunity to
respond to the concerns. The Court found that no further consultation with the
province was required in the circumstances.
The Court also rejected the argument that the officer was
required to conduct an interview or make another verification call. The
fairness letter clearly identified the concern, and the applicant had access to
the relevant facts and evidence needed to explain the discrepancy.
The Court emphasized that where an applicant is given a
meaningful opportunity to respond to a misrepresentation concern but provides
an implausible explanation, the officer is entitled to reject that explanation.
The applicant could have provided additional corroborating
evidence, including documentation from other employees or evidence supporting
his claimed employment. He did not do so.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review and upheld the finding of misrepresentation and the refusal of the
provincial nominee permanent residence application.
Case Citation:
Bhamra v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2014 FC 239 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






