Kevin Ejiafe Akpoduado sought
judicial review after a visa officer refused his Federal Skilled Worker
permanent residence application and found him inadmissible for five years for
misrepresentation. The dispute concerned whether he had worked at Guaranty
Trust Bank as a Cash Receipt Supervisor under NOC 1212. Although the Court
rejected his procedural fairness arguments, it found the decision unreasonable
because the officer failed to consider his post-decision reconsideration
request despite unusual evidence surrounding the disputed employment reference.
Key Principle
A visa officer is not required to
provide an applicant with a continuing “running score” by issuing a new
procedural fairness letter whenever the applicant’s own response creates a new
concern. However, where unusual circumstances and subsequent evidence
materially clarify the basis of a refusal, an officer’s failure to consider a
request for reconsideration may render the decision unreasonable, particularly
where direct verification could resolve the central factual dispute.
Background
Akpoduado, a Nigerian citizen,
applied for permanent residence as a Federal Skilled Worker based on employment
as a Cash Receipt Supervisor at GT Bank. His supervisor provided a reference
describing that position and his duties.
GT Bank later told immigration
officials that the reference was not signed according to the bank’s mandate and
could not be confirmed. A procedural fairness letter warned Akpoduado that the
employment letter might be fraudulent. He explained that Human Resources would
not issue letters containing job descriptions, so he obtained one from his
direct supervisor.
His response included official
bank documents identifying him as a Banking Officer, but none identifying him
as a Cash Receipt Supervisor. The officer therefore concluded that he had not
established the claimed CRS experience and refused the application for
misrepresentation.
Court Findings
• No Second Fairness Letter
Was Required
The Court rejected the argument
that procedural fairness required another letter after Akpoduado’s response
created a new discrepancy between “Banking Officer” and “Cash Receipt
Supervisor.” Requiring a second letter in these circumstances would amount to
giving an applicant a running score. The original allegation that the reference
might be fraudulent was sufficiently broad to place its contents, including the
stated position and duties, in issue.
• Evidence Did Not Establish
the Dual Job Description Before Refusal
Akpoduado only explained after
refusal that “Banking Officer” was his formal title while “Cash Receipt
Supervisor” described his trade or function. The employee handbook submitted
with that explanation did not substantiate those categories. The officer therefore
had no bank document before the refusal that clearly established that he could
simultaneously hold both descriptions.
• Reconsideration Request Had
to Be Addressed
The decisive error was the
failure to consider Akpoduado’s reconsideration request. The Court emphasized
the unusual circumstances: GT Bank confirmed his employment, its denial could
relate to internal signing rules rather than falsity, and Akpoduado had
documented that HR would not provide the detailed reference required for
immigration purposes. The Court directed that reconsideration include direct
contact with his supervisor, preferably by telephone, to verify the reference,
job title and duties.
Outcome
The Federal Court granted
judicial review and ordered that Akpoduado’s permanent residence application be
reconsidered in accordance with its directions. No question was certified for
appeal.
Case
Citation:
Akpoduado v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2017 FC 103 (CanLII)
Written by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






