The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a Federal Skilled
Worker permanent residence application involving a family whose young son had
cerebral palsy.
The Court upheld the refusal because the family’s financial
and caregiving plan did not adequately demonstrate how the child’s specialized
medical and social services needs would be met without placing an excessive
demand on Canadian public services.
Key Principle
Under paragraph 38(1)(c) of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Act (IRPA), as applicable in 2012, an applicant could be found
medically inadmissible where their health condition might reasonably be
expected to cause excessive demand on health or social services.
Immigration officers must conduct individualized assessments
that consider an applicant’s medical needs, financial resources and proposed
private care arrangements. However, a general willingness to pay is
insufficient without a credible, practical and detailed plan.
Background
Susanna Julia De Hoedt Daniel, a Sri Lankan citizen, applied
for permanent residence under the Federal Skilled Worker Class in August 2010.
Her son, Jordan, was born in New Zealand in 2009 and had
cerebral palsy involving developmental delays and motor difficulties.
A medical assessment identified several anticipated needs,
including early intervention programs, special education, respite care,
mobility equipment and specialized therapies.
Following a procedural fairness letter, the family submitted
a financial plan outlining their anticipated Canadian income, insurance
coverage, community assistance and a goal of accumulating $300,000 in savings
over ten years.
They also provided letters from relatives, church members
and community supporters offering accommodation, childcare, financial
assistance and respite care.
Nevertheless, the immigration officer concluded that the
plan did not adequately establish how Jordan’s specialized needs would actually
be met.
Court Findings
First, the officer conducted an individualized medical
assessment.
The officer considered Jordan’s particular condition,
anticipated service requirements and the family’s proposed arrangements rather
than relying solely on his diagnosis.
Second, the financial plan lacked sufficient practical
detail.
The Court found that projected savings and future
fundraising depended on assumptions that were not adequately supported.
Third, the insurance coverage was insufficient.
Although the insurance would cover some services, it did not
adequately address Jordan’s continuing need for specialized therapies and care.
Fourth, the proposed community support did not establish a
viable care arrangement.
The letters demonstrated considerable goodwill, but the
supporters had not established the specialized qualifications necessary to meet
Jordan’s particular needs.
Fifth, the plan failed to identify an appropriate
multidisciplinary care team.
The family had not provided sufficiently detailed
arrangements for qualified professionals to assess, organize and deliver
Jordan’s developmental services.
Sixth, the officer did not ignore material evidence.
The Court found that the refusal letter and GCMS notes
demonstrated consideration of the financial plan, insurance and supporting
documentation.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed judicial review and upheld the
refusal on medical inadmissibility grounds.
The decision confirms that financial capacity, family
support and genuine intentions must be supported by a workable, individualized
plan identifying appropriate services, qualified providers and realistic
arrangements for payment and delivery.
Although dismissing the application, the Court encouraged
the family and its supporters to prepare a stronger plan and suggested that
Canadian authorities give priority to a renewed application in recognition of
their previous efforts.
No question of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
De Hoedt Daniel v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 1391 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






