The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a Federal Skilled
Worker permanent residence application submitted by an Iranian physician.
The applicant argued that an unauthorized immigration
consultant had included a fraudulent IELTS test report without his knowledge.
The Court upheld the refusal, finding that the document
constituted a material misrepresentation and that the consultant’s alleged
misconduct did not excuse the applicant’s responsibility.
Key Principle
Under paragraph 40(1)(a) of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Act (IRPA), a foreign national may be found inadmissible for
directly or indirectly misrepresenting material facts.
An applicant may be held responsible for a fraudulent
document submitted by an immigration representative, even without proven
personal knowledge or intent, unless exceptional circumstances justify a
recognized exception.
The submission of genuine supporting documentation at a
later stage does not automatically remove an earlier material
misrepresentation.
Background
Daryoush Shahin, an Iranian physician, applied for permanent
residence through the Federal Skilled Worker category in August 2005.
He hired Arash Rahmatian, an unauthorized immigration
consultant, to prepare the application.
Mr. Shahin acknowledged signing the application but
maintained that the consultant included an IELTS test report without his
knowledge.
He explained that the consultant had advised him to complete
the language examination later because processing could take several years.
In September 2010, Mr. Shahin submitted updated information,
including genuine IELTS results obtained in 2009.
However, immigration authorities discovered the fraudulent
document associated with his original application.
A procedural fairness letter was issued in May 2011.
Mr. Shahin responded that he had never submitted IELTS
results in 2005.
In July 2011, immigration authorities found him inadmissible
for misrepresentation.
Court Findings
The Federal Court upheld the decision.
First, the false IELTS report was capable of misleading
immigration authorities.
Its appearance imitated an official language test report and
could create the impression that the applicant had met the required language
criteria.
Second, the misrepresentation was material.
A fraudulent language test could influence whether an
application was accepted for processing or assessed as complete.
Third, the applicant’s later denial did not establish an
exception to misrepresentation inadmissibility.
The Court emphasized that applicants have a duty to verify
the accuracy of information submitted by their representatives.
Fourth, the applicant received procedural fairness.
Immigration authorities disclosed their concerns, provided
an opportunity to respond and considered the explanation before reaching the
inadmissibility finding.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed judicial review and upheld the
refusal of permanent residence.
The decision confirms that an applicant’s failure to verify
documents submitted by a representative may result in serious immigration
consequences, notwithstanding later claims of consultant fraud.
No question of general importance was certified.
Case Citation:
Shahin v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2012 FC 423 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst






