The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a father’s
application to sponsor his daughter for permanent residence.
The father had become a permanent resident of Canada years
earlier but had not declared the daughter in his own permanent residence
application. As a result, she had not been examined as his dependent.
The visa officer concluded that she was excluded from the
family class under paragraph 117(9)(d) of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Regulations and also refused the request for humanitarian and
compassionate relief.
The Federal Court dismissed the judicial review.
Key Principle
Under the law considered in this case, a dependent family
member who was not declared and examined when the sponsor became a permanent
resident could later be excluded from sponsorship under the family class.
The case also illustrates an important procedural point:
where a statutory appeal to the Immigration Appeal Division is available, that
appeal generally must be exhausted before the Federal Court can review the same
family-class determination.
H&C relief may still be requested, but it remains discretionary
and does not automatically overcome the excluded-family-member rule.
Background
The sponsor came to Canada from Nigeria and eventually
obtained permanent residence through spousal sponsorship in 2002. He became a
Canadian citizen in 2006.
He stated that, while travelling in Liberia in 1995, he had
a brief relationship with the daughter’s mother but did not know she had become
pregnant.
According to the sponsor, he first learned about his
daughter years later during a trip to Nigeria. A DNA test subsequently
confirmed that he was her biological father.
In 2013, he submitted an application to sponsor her for
permanent residence.
IRCC advised him that he was ineligible to sponsor her
because she had not been declared or examined when he obtained permanent
residence.
The application proceeded nevertheless, with a request for
H&C consideration. The visa officer ultimately refused both the
family-class application and the H&C request.
Court Findings
The Court first found that the father himself did not have
standing to challenge the refusal merely because he was affected emotionally by
his daughter’s inability to immigrate.
His legal rights as a Canadian citizen were not directly
affected by the officer’s decision. However, the Court continued its analysis
because the daughter was also properly named as an applicant.
The Court then addressed the family-class issue.
The father had already appealed the refusal to the
Immigration Appeal Division. The IAD dismissed that appeal, and no judicial
review of the IAD decision had been brought.
The Federal Court held that judicial review is generally a
remedy of last resort. Where Parliament provides a statutory appeal process,
applicants must ordinarily complete that process before asking the Federal
Court to review the original decision.
Reviewing the visa officer’s family-class determination
after the IAD had already ruled on the same issue would amount to an improper
collateral attack on the IAD decision.
The Court also found no reviewable error in the officer’s
H&C analysis.
It rejected the argument that international obligations
concerning family reunification required a positive H&C decision. H&C
authority is discretionary and does not require approval in every case
involving family separation.
The Court further confirmed that there was no automatic
right to an oral interview in an H&C application, even though the
daughter had been 17 when the request was made.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review.
It found no basis to interfere with the officer’s H&C
assessment and held that the family-class issue could not be relitigated
through judicial review of the original visa officer decision after the IAD had
already decided the appeal.
Case Citation:
Chinenye v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 378 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






