The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a Federal Skilled
Worker permanent residence application submitted by a Pakistani citizen whose
educational credentials were assessed by World Education Services (WES).
The Court upheld the refusal because the applicant’s
Educational Credential Assessment (ECA) identified the Canadian equivalent of
her years of post-secondary study but did not establish equivalency to a
completed Canadian post-secondary diploma, degree or certificate.
Key Principle
Under sections 73, 75 and 78 of the Immigration and Refugee
Protection Regulations (IRPR), as applicable in 2013, Federal Skilled Worker
applicants were awarded education points based on their Canadian educational
credentials or recognized foreign educational equivalencies.
An ECA indicating that foreign education is equivalent to a
specified number of years of Canadian study does not necessarily establish
equivalency to a completed Canadian educational credential. The distinction can
significantly affect the education points awarded under the Federal Skilled
Worker selection system.
Background
Minaa Ijaz, a Pakistani citizen, applied for permanent
residence under the Federal Skilled Worker Class on May 4, 2013, identifying
her occupation as Financial Analyst, NOC 1112.
She submitted a WES Credential Evaluation and Authentication
Report covering three qualifications:
- A
Higher Secondary Certificate, assessed as equivalent to a Canadian
secondary school diploma.
- A
Bachelor of Science degree from the University of Punjab, assessed as
equivalent to two years of Canadian undergraduate study.
- Professional
qualifications from the Institute of Cost and Management Accountants of
Pakistan, assessed as equivalent to two years of Canadian professional
study.
On June 19, 2013, the visa officer refused the application,
awarding only 5 education points and a total of 57 points against the required
67.
The applicant argued that she should have received at least
19 education points, or potentially 23, based on her post-secondary
qualifications.
Court Findings
First, an ECA must be interpreted according to its actual
findings.
The Court distinguished recognition of completed foreign
qualifications from an assessment establishing equivalency to a completed
Canadian credential.
Second, the WES report did not confirm a completed Canadian
post-secondary equivalent.
Although the applicant’s Bachelor of Science degree
represented two years of Canadian undergraduate study, WES did not identify it
as equivalent to a completed Canadian two-year post-secondary credential or
bachelor’s degree.
Third, the officer correctly treated the ECA as conclusive
evidence.
Under subsection 75(8) of the IRPR, the officer was bound by
the equivalency determination. However, the officer could reasonably interpret
what the report established.
Fourth, the regulatory framework supported the requirement
for a completed credential.
The Court examined the definition of a Canadian educational
credential, the regulatory amendments and the former OP 6-C operational manual.
These materials supported awarding points based on
equivalency to a completed Canadian qualification.
Fifth, the officer’s interpretation was reasonable.
The Court acknowledged that the applicant’s alternative
interpretation was also potentially reasonable. Nevertheless, applying the
administrative law framework then governing the case, the Court deferred to the
officer’s interpretation.
Sixth, the Court recognized uncertainty in the regulations.
Justice Strickland observed that both the wording of the WES
report and the relevant regulatory provisions could have been clearer.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed judicial review, maintaining the
refusal based on the applicant’s insufficient selection points.
However, the Court certified a question of general
importance concerning whether an ECA must expressly identify equivalency to a
completed Canadian educational credential or whether an assessment expressed in
years of Canadian-equivalent study is sufficient.
The decision highlights the importance of examining the
exact wording of an Educational Credential Assessment. An applicant may possess
completed foreign post-secondary qualifications yet receive fewer immigration
selection points if the ECA does not establish their equivalency to completed
Canadian credentials.
The judgment reflects the regulatory and judicial review
framework applicable in 2015. The certified issue and subsequent jurisprudence
should be checked before relying on the decision as a statement of current law.
Case Citation:
Ijaz v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 67 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and
Statistics Analyst





