The Federal Court dismissed the
application for judicial review of a refusal to extend an LMIA-exempt work
permit under the International Mobility Program (IMP), specifically the
entrepreneur/self-employed category under paragraph 205(a) of the IRPR and C11
policy. The Court held that the Officer reasonably assessed whether the
Applicant’s business would generate a significant social, economic, or cultural
benefit to Canada and was not bound by the earlier decision granting the
initial LMIA-exempt work permit. Pasted text
Key Principle
An applicant seeking an extension
of an LMIA-exempt work permit under the C11 framework must establish, on the
evidence submitted with the extension application, that the proposed work
continues to satisfy the applicable requirements, including a significant
social, economic, or cultural benefit to Canadians or permanent residents. A
previous approval does not bind an officer considering a subsequent extension
application. Pasted text
Background
The Applicant, a Vietnamese
citizen with a master’s degree in music, was a composer and conductor who had
co-founded a Canadian company. He initially received a two-year LMIA-exempt
work permit under the IMP. His spouse received an open work permit and their
two children received temporary resident and study permits.
In October 2023, the family
applied to extend their status. The Officer refused the Applicant’s extension
on the basis that he had not established that he continued to qualify for an
LMIA exemption under paragraph 205(a). The spouse’s application was refused as
a consequence. Pasted text
Court Findings
• The Officer properly
assessed the C11 requirements. The Officer found that the Applicant had not
provided a future plan or indicated when he intended to return to Vietnam. The
Officer also found that the company’s financial records did not support the
proposed expansion or hiring of additional Canadian staff.
• Community support was
considered. The Applicant argued that the Officer had ignored numerous
letters from the Vietnamese-Canadian community. The Court disagreed. The GCMS
notes showed that the Officer considered the reference letters, the Applicant’s
church-choir involvement, and the company’s public performance. The Officer was
entitled to weigh that evidence against the C11 requirements. Pasted text
• Previous approval was not
determinative. The Court rejected the argument that the Officer was
required to follow the earlier decision granting the initial IMP work permit.
Each extension application had to be assessed based on the evidence and
submissions before the Officer at that time.
• No fettering of discretion.
The Court rejected the argument that applying the C11 requirements amounted to
fettering the discretion under paragraph 205(a). The Officer reasonably
concluded that the Applicant had failed to demonstrate a significant social,
cultural, or economic benefit or opportunity for Canadians. Pasted text
• COVID-19 argument was not
properly before the Court. The Applicant had not raised the impact of
COVID-19 restrictions before the Officer. The Court held that judicial review
generally proceeds on the administrative record and that an applicant cannot
challenge a decision based on the Officer’s failure to address an issue that
was never raised. Pasted text
Outcome
The Court found that the Officer
grappled with the relevant C11 requirements and the evidence and provided a
logical and rational chain of analysis. The application for judicial review was
therefore dismissed, with no certified question.
Case
Citation:
Nguyen v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2025 FC 143 (CanLII)
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian
Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst





