The Federal Court granted three
applications for judicial review concerning refusals of LMIA-exempt work
permits under the Start-Up Business Class Program. The Court found that the
officer applied criteria inconsistent with the Program, improperly relied on
family ties and purpose of visit, and failed to meaningfully engage with
evidence supporting the applicants’ ability to perform the proposed work.
Pasted text
Key Principle
A Start-Up Visa work permit
application must be assessed within the specific framework of the Program.
Where the Program contemplates an LMIA-exempt work permit, an officer cannot
reasonably fault an applicant for failing to first obtain an LMIA or apply
criteria associated with a different LMIA-exemption category. Similarly, the
existence of dual intent does not, without reasonable justification, support a
finding that an applicant will fail to leave Canada. Pasted text Pasted text
Background
The Applicants, three business
partners from Kazakhstan, sought work permits to establish an innovative
greenhouse business in Manitoba. Each submitted a Commitment Certificate and
Letter of Support from a designated entity, an IMM-5802 form, proof of the
employer compliance fee, and evidence of sufficient funds. The designated
entity also confirmed that the Applicants were essential to the business and
required to enter Canada to begin its development. Pasted text
The officer refused the
applications after finding insufficient evidence of personal renown and
expertise, failure to attempt to obtain an LMIA, inability to perform the
proposed work, and insufficient evidence that the Applicants would leave Canada
at the end of their authorized stay. The officer also relied on the fact that
the proposed business had not yet been incorporated and noted the absence of
language-test results. Pasted text
Court Findings
• Wrong LMIA-exempt
assessment: The Court found the officer applied the wrong criteria by
treating C10 applications as intended for persons of international renown and
requiring efforts to obtain an LMIA first. The Program specifically
contemplated an LMIA-exempt work permit, and C10 was identified in IRCC
guidance as the applicable code. The officer failed to explain why the broader
economic-benefit language in IRPR 205(a) was being restricted in this manner.
Pasted text
• Family ties and dual intent:
Relying on family ties and the purpose of the visit to conclude that the
Applicants would not leave Canada was unreasonable. The Program itself
contemplated temporary entry to Canada to begin operating the start-up while
pursuing permanent residence. The Court characterized this as a classic case of
dual intent under IRPA s 22(2). Pasted text
• Failure to engage with
evidence: The officer failed to meaningfully address the Commitment
Certificates, Letters of Support, education, experience, and proposed job
descriptions when finding that the Applicants could not perform the work
sought. Pasted text
• Language requirement:
Although language proficiency was required for permanent residence under the
Program, it was not a requirement for the work permit. If language ability was
nevertheless relevant to the Applicants’ capacity to perform the proposed work,
the officer was required to explain why their language ability was inadequate.
Pasted text
• Unincorporated business:
The Court found it unreasonable to rely on the absence of an incorporated
business because the Program permitted applicants to seek the work permit
before incorporation, and the Applicants had indicated their intention to
incorporate after arrival. Pasted text
• Peer review: Peer review
was discretionary rather than mandatory. The failure to request peer review did
not itself make the decisions unreasonable. Pasted text
Outcome
The Court granted all three
judicial reviews and ordered that the work permit applications be redetermined
by a different officer within 60 days. The Court declined to direct issuance of
the work permits and made no order as to costs.
Case
Citation :
Serimbetov v. Canada (Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship), 2022 FC 1130 (CanLII) [2023] 1 FCR 425
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad
Abrar (Barrister and
Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian
Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






