The Federal Court reviewed the refusal of a spousal
sponsorship case involving a Canadian citizen and her husband from Sri Lanka.
The husband had failed to disclose important parts of his
travel history, including time spent in France, St. Martin and Guadeloupe,
periods of detention, and the use of a false Canadian passport.
The Immigration Appeal Division found that these omissions
amounted to misrepresentation and also refused humanitarian and compassionate
relief.
The Federal Court upheld that decision.
Key Principle
Applicants must provide complete and truthful information
in immigration applications.
Failing to disclose important facts can amount to
misrepresentation where the missing information could affect how immigration
authorities assess the application.
A later admission does not necessarily correct the problem,
especially where the truth is disclosed only after the applicant is confronted
with contradictory evidence.
Misrepresentation can also become an important negative
factor when humanitarian and compassionate relief is being considered.
Background
The Canadian sponsor married her husband in 2008 and later
applied to sponsor him for permanent residence.
In his immigration application, the husband did not disclose
several important parts of his travel history between 2000 and 2008.
He failed to mention travel to France, St. Martin and
Guadeloupe, time spent in custody in St. Martin and Guadeloupe, and the fact
that he had travelled from France to St. Martin using a false Canadian
passport.
During an interview with a visa officer, he initially denied
those trips.
He admitted the information only after the officer
confronted him with evidence showing that the travel had occurred.
The visa officer refused the application on the basis of
misrepresentation.
The Immigration Appeal Division later upheld that finding
and also refused humanitarian and compassionate relief.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the Immigration Appeal Division
reasonably concluded that the husband had made a material misrepresentation.
The undisclosed information was important because it
prevented the visa officer from fully assessing issues relating to criminality,
security and even the genuineness of the marriage.
The Court also rejected the argument that the period of
inadmissibility should have started from the original visa officer’s decision.
Under the law in force at the time, the Court held that
where the case was appealed to the Immigration Appeal Division, the final
determination of inadmissibility occurred when the IAD made its decision. The
applicable two-year inadmissibility period therefore began from that date.
The Court also upheld the refusal of humanitarian and
compassionate relief.
The IAD had considered positive factors, including the
genuine relationship between the spouses, but it also considered the
seriousness of the misrepresentation and the applicants’ lack of remorse.
The husband admitted the truth only after being confronted
with contrary evidence. The Canadian spouse also knew about the inaccurate
information and chose not to correct the application immediately.
The Court found that the IAD had properly weighed the
positive and negative factors rather than simply rejecting the H&C request
because misrepresentation had occurred.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review and upheld the IAD’s decision.
The case shows why applicants should disclose their complete
immigration, travel and personal history, even where they believe certain
information may be damaging to the application.
Failing to disclose material information can create a much
more serious problem than the underlying fact itself, particularly where the
omission affects an officer’s ability to properly assess the application.
Historical Note: At the time of this decision, the applicable
misrepresentation inadmissibility period discussed by the Court was two years.
The legislation has since changed, and the current consequences of
misrepresentation must be assessed under the law in force at the relevant time.
Case Citation:
Thavarasa v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 625 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






