The Federal Court reviewed an inadmissibility decision
involving a permanent resident who had lived in Canada since 1967.
The applicant had been convicted in 1996 of conspiracy to
traffic cocaine. Many years later, immigration authorities began
inadmissibility proceedings and found him inadmissible for both serious
criminality and organized criminality.
The applicant challenged the organized criminality finding
and also argued that the 17-year delay in starting the proceedings was unfair.
The Federal Court rejected those arguments and upheld the
inadmissibility decision.
Key Principle
A person may be found inadmissible for organized criminality
where there are reasonable grounds to believe that they were a member of
a criminal organization or participated in organized criminal activity.
The person does not need to hold formal membership, have a
membership card, or occupy a leadership role.
The concept of membership is interpreted broadly, and past
membership or association may still be relevant.
A long delay before immigration proceedings begin does not
automatically amount to an abuse of process. The person must generally show
serious prejudice affecting the fairness of the proceeding.
Background
The applicant was an Italian citizen who became a permanent
resident of Canada in 1967.
In 1996, he was arrested while attempting to pick up
approximately 170 kilograms of cocaine.
He later pleaded guilty to conspiracy to traffic cocaine and
received a lengthy prison sentence.
Other individuals connected to the same case were associated
with the Cotroni crime family in Montréal.
In 2006, the applicant was arrested again during Operation
Colisée, an investigation targeting organized crime, although no charges were
ultimately brought against him.
In 2013, immigration authorities prepared inadmissibility
reports against him.
The Immigration Division concluded that there were
reasonable grounds to believe that the applicant had been involved with a
criminal organization and had participated in organized criminal activity.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the Immigration Division
reasonably assessed the evidence.
The Court explained that the standard of proof in an
inadmissibility proceeding is different from the criminal standard of proof
beyond a reasonable doubt.
For organized criminality, the question is whether there are
reasonable grounds to believe the relevant facts occurred. This requires
more than suspicion, but less than proof on a balance of probabilities.
The Immigration Division relied on several pieces of
evidence, including the applicant’s employment relationship with individuals
connected to organized crime, his involvement in the 1996 cocaine transaction,
his knowledge of the Cotroni family, and documentary evidence from law
enforcement and correctional authorities.
The Court found that this evidence provided an objective
basis for concluding that the applicant had participated in organized criminal
activity.
The Court also confirmed that membership in a criminal
organization is interpreted broadly.
A person does not need to prove formal membership through
documents or official status. Evidence of a close and continuing association,
trust within the organization, and participation in its activities may be
sufficient.
The Court also noted that current membership is not
required. Past membership or association can still support an inadmissibility
finding.
The applicant also argued that the 17-year delay between his
criminal conviction and the immigration proceedings amounted to an abuse of
process.
The Court disagreed.
It found that delay alone was not enough. The applicant had
to establish serious prejudice affecting his ability to defend himself or
making the proceeding fundamentally unfair.
The evidence did not show that the delay had caused that
level of prejudice. The Court therefore found no abuse of process.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review and upheld the finding of inadmissibility for organized criminality.
The case shows that serious immigration consequences can
arise many years after criminal conduct or involvement with a criminal
organization.
It also demonstrates that a person does not need to be a
formal or senior member of a criminal organization to face inadmissibility. The
overall evidence concerning the person’s association, participation and
knowledge may be sufficient.
Case Citation:
Torre v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 591 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






