The Federal Court reviewed a finding that a caregiver was
inadmissible to Canada for misrepresentation.
The applicant had entered Canada through the former Live-In
Caregiver Program. However, after arriving, she did not actually work full-time
for the employers or live in their home as required.
The Immigration Division found that the applicant and the
employers had created the appearance that she was working as a caregiver by
using pay cheques and salary records that did not reflect genuine employment.
The Federal Court upheld the misrepresentation finding.
Key Principle
Misrepresentation under Canadian immigration law can be direct
or indirect.
An applicant may face consequences even where misleading
information is provided through another person, such as an employer or family
member.
The Court also confirmed that immigration misrepresentation
does not always require proof that the applicant intentionally tried to deceive
immigration authorities.
Background
The applicant was a citizen of China who obtained a
temporary resident visa and work permit through the Live-In Caregiver Program.
She was expected to work as a full-time caregiver for two
children and live in the employers’ home.
However, by the time she arrived in Canada, the children’s
grandparents were already caring for them and were occupying the room that had
been intended for the applicant.
As a result, the caregiver position for which the work
authorization had been obtained was effectively no longer available.
Immigration authorities were not advised that these
circumstances had changed.
The Immigration Division later found that the applicant and
her employers participated in a financial arrangement designed to make it
appear that she continued to work as a caregiver.
The employer issued cheques to the applicant. She deposited
the cheques, withdrew the money and returned the funds to the employer. Salary
information was then reported to the Canada Revenue Agency as though genuine
employment had occurred.
Court Findings
The Federal Court found that the Immigration Division
reasonably concluded that the applicant had been involved in indirect
misrepresentation.
The Court emphasized that section 40(1)(a) of the
Immigration and Refugee Protection Act applies where a person directly or
indirectly misrepresents or withholds material facts that could lead to an
error in the administration of immigration law.
The applicant argued that she was essentially the victim of
the employers’ conduct and should not be held responsible for their actions.
The Court rejected that argument on the facts of the case.
There was evidence that the applicant participated in the
arrangement used to create the appearance of employment after she arrived in
Canada. The Immigration Division had described the arrangement as a “ruse”
intended to mislead government authorities.
The Court also noted that misrepresentation can still arise
where misleading information is communicated through a third party.
It further stated that there was evidence suggesting the
applicant, through her sister, may have known before arriving in Canada that
the caregiver position was no longer genuinely available.
The applicant also argued that she had been denied
procedural fairness because the Immigration Division refused to summon the
employer’s mother to testify.
The Court rejected this argument as well.
The Immigration Division had already heard extensive
evidence about the grandparents’ involvement and reasonably concluded that the
grandmother’s testimony would have only a limited impact on the central issues.
The Court therefore found that the hearing had been fair.
Outcome
The Federal Court dismissed the application for judicial
review and upheld the finding of inadmissibility for misrepresentation.
The case shows that applicants should immediately disclose
important changes affecting the basis of their immigration status or work
authorization.
It also demonstrates that participating in arrangements that
create false employment records, payroll documents or other misleading evidence
can result in serious immigration consequences, even where other people were
also involved.
Case Citation:
Wang v. Canada (Citizenship and Immigration), 2015 FC 647 CanLII
Prepared by:
Dr. Muhammad Abrar (Barrister and Solicitor)
Author | Writer | Mentor | Legal Researcher | Canadian Immigration Case Law and Statistics Analyst






